makci的部落格

This is substantially look-alike asking: "Is Medicine or Psychology scientific?" The reply is: "Some aspects are completely knowledge base and quite a few are not. As well, few practitioners are more effective than others. Also, numerous aspects of Psychology require projective techniques (e.g. the Rorschach Inkblot testing) which believe heavily on the adeptness of the practitioner and do not glibly pedestal up to "hard core" finding measures. They can, nevertheless, be agreed as irrefutable if they group the criteria of worldwide or holistic determination.

As to writing analysis, The International Graphoanalysis Society has had a investigation division since 1929 and, in its publication: An Annotated Bibliography of Studies in Handwriting Analysis Research, altered 1985, Dr. James C. Crumbaugh (Mississippi Psychologist of the Year, 1989), summarizes almost 240 studies bearing on various aspects of graphology. Dr. Crumbaugh points out that these studies contain little than two percentage of studies conducted on this subject field and he considers these to be the best thoughtful studies conducted by scholars and published in honoured publications.

Dr. Crumbaugh, in a reprint entitled: Graphoanalytic Cues, in the beginning published in The Encyclopedia of Clinical Assessment, manuscript 11, 1980, points to studies that: "seem to be the peak decisive in demonstrating a medical justification for the belief that script can be as reasonable in self appraisal as the remaining principal projective techniques." He additional points out that a number of psychologists, psychiatrists and another physicians have interpreted groundwork in handwriting investigation and that, in Germany, many universities call for grooming in Graphology as part of a set of their Ph.D. schema in Psychology.

So yes, aspects of writing investigating can be proven. The Graphoanalytic group appears to make happy the tests of intercontinental and holistic validation, and studies are continued to exhibit this. Other schools of may or may not be solid but, undeniably, this parcel of land is transmittable the glare of publicity and getting hold of the astonishment of the irrefutable colony.

Today, handwriting investigating is the subject of noticeably proven inquest beside dozens, if not hundreds of studies being conducted and published annually, more of them by momentous scholars.